Devon Island Expedition

Devon Island Expedition
This blog features educational updates on my Devon Island Expedition of July 14-20, 2007. Other sites:,

Thursday, October 14, 2010

On Space Exploration, Radiation and Monkeys!

So, I’m sitting here at the sixteenth conference on Solid State Dosimetry (SSD16), thinking about monkeys, radiation and space exploration. The conference is only held every three years, so it’s been going on now for nearly fifty! That’s how hard it is to measure radiation, and come up with meaningful interpretations of the results.

The main purpose of the conference involves neither monkeys nor space exploration. Most of the dosimeter work is focused on medical applications, to advance the state of the art for more precise radiation treatment of cancer patients. But the part in which I am involved, specifically deals with space exploration applications.

Radiation is the single biggest threat to astronaut health in long duration flight. This is especially true for flights that would occur away from the Van Allen Radiation Belts, which offer significant protection to all of us, who are safely cocooned in it’s warm embrace. Even in Low Earth Orbit (LEO), astronauts are still protected to a large degree from charged particles. The heavy artillery still gets through (gamma rays, neutrons, some protons), but the electrons and other charged ions are caught in the electromagnetic field lines. Astronauts who ventured to the Moon were outside of the belts, as would be astronauts who travel to Near Earth Objects (NEO’s), Lagrange Points or any other far destination (Mars, anyone?). A solar flare (or event, in the parlance of the field) could be fatal. NASA worried quite a bit about that possibility during the Apollo program.

It was announced in this morning’s conference session, that last night we had a solar event. I immediately thought of my friends aboard the International Space Station (ISS). Misha and his crew are due to return to Earth tomorrow. They were a day late, and could be exposed to elevated radiation levels.

We had a solar event during my stint as the Commander of ISS Expedition 10. It was eerie. We got the call from Mission Control, and were advised during which specific times we were to retreat to the “more heavily shielded” portions of the station. More heavily shielded? Uh huh…..For me, that meant the sleep station in the US Segment, which had plastic shielding inserted into the fabric walls. They are supposed to catch a few heavy particles, but they seemed awfully thin to me. Salizhan was directed to the middle of the Zvezda core module, which was where there was more machinery around the middle. Great. After the event had passed, the radiation detectors were still registering levels about ten times normal. Great again. Well, what could we do? This was one of the prices we had to pay, for the privilege of spaceflight. At least we had detectors, which allowed estimates of the cumulative doses that we received (we were told “all good!” post-flight, by the NASA folks. Uh huh……).

There are three things we need to figure out radiation wise, in order to explore in a sustained fashion, beyond LEO: (1) Detection; (2) Shielding; (3) Treatment. This conference deals with the first, detection. There is ongoing work in the other two fields as well. Shielding is a tricky deal. It would seem that one simply would need to find a pile of lead and hide inside of it. Not so simple. Gamma rays and protons punch into high-Z materials and cause secondary emissions, which could actually be much more harmful to biologics like us. As for treatment, there are researchers working on drugs and nano-materials, which would scoop up free radicals in our blood, caused by radiation exposure. Good work in all three, but plenty more to do.

So, where then do the monkeys come in? Monkeys have played an important role in space exploration, since the beginning. The first “American” in space was Ham the monkey, who flew inside of a Mercury capsule before Alan Shepard. You may have heard about planned monkey radiation experiments, and the recent protests against them. I understand the necessity of animal experiments in developing drugs and treatments, but I must admit that this one has me scratching my head a bit.

I have no doubt that some advances in scientific knowledge would be realized through these planned experiments, but I’m an operational guy (despite my Ph.D.). How would these experiments help us to survive in deep space? I don’t see it. The bottom line, is that exposure to high levels of radiation is bad. We need to figure out how to detect for, and protect against exposure, as well as to treat for exposure, if it occurs.

I’m a big fan of Curious George. Let’s leave him alone this time.

Leroy Chiao


Marcel F. Williams said...

This is one of the reasons why I believe that a Moon base should be placed at one of the lunar poles so that we can test various types of radiation shielding with astronauts staying at such facilities at least a year or more.

Lunar regolith, lunar water, and even lunar hydrogen (liquid hydrogen or slush hydrogen) derived from the lunar poles could be used to test various levels of shielding thickness against solar events, general galactic radiation, and heavy nuclei over months and even years.

Such radiation shielding resources could also be exported from the Moon to an L1 launch point for manned interplanetary journeys a lot cheaper than exporting them from the Earth's huge gravity well thanks to the substantially lower delta-v requirements.

Huaixing said...

We'd better testing radiation on rats first.

Neal Thompson said...

Hi Leroy, I just stumbled across your blog, and I'm glad I did. I'm the author of a biography of Alan Shepard ("Light This Candle: The Life & Times of Alan Shepard, America's First Spaceman"), and wanted to tell you I've enjoyed reading your thoughts on the state of space exploration. Thanks...
Neal Thompson

Matt Wronkiewicz said...

My understanding of the monkey radiation experiments was that the animals would be exposed to high doses of radiation at the level of what you might get on a trip to Mars during a solar flare. The theory being tested is that this level of radiation might cause psychological effects, such as impaired judgement. Impaired judgement during a solar storm could be catastrophic during a deep space mission, and it's something that will have to be investigated at some point in the coming decade if we're serious about human BEO missions. It was this specific data that the monkey team found lacking, not the long-term low-dose effects. Luckily the PETA activists commenting on Lori's blog have volunteered specific classes of less-desirable humans to stand in for the monkeys should we decide to go ahead with the experiment. Hopefully that will be an acceptable compromise for everyone.

Ohm Jal said...

nice article and offering niche space information

Jiri Polak said...

Dear Leroy, it is ever interesting reading your blog. Radiation protection is outmost important for the space development into the future - however to measure protection we need dectors first. I hope your future space plan would include this.
Jiri Polak, Prague

jimmy wilson said...

Superb publish I adore your own article enjoy and the choice of identified as much as possible, you are doing a great task the majority of other folks just like you as a result of in which sort of helpful sites produce understanding for you to people related to a lot of things. I go through other sorts of useful weblogs from your internet sites and also I am a great deal fascinated together with your running a blog ability, My spouse and i also began to create sites and this form weblogs truly guide me personally away. We already book-marked your own web site and distributed your own sites to help my personal friends not simply myself however these people just like your blogging expertise, hope anyone generate a lot more fascinating blogs like this just one along with good luck to your foreseeable future blogs.

Jimmy Wilson from Smallville Red Leather Jacket